Comments to
- M.M. Attar, J.D. Scantlebury
- Polyaniline as a possible inhibitor for the corrosion of mild steel
J. Corr. Sci. Eng., Vol 1, paper 8
Date: Mon, 9 Feb 1998 21:43:46 +0100 (MET)
To: "Bob Cottis" @fs1.cp.umist.ac.uk>
From: "Dr. Bernhard Wessling" @zipperling.do.eunet.de>
Subject: Re: Polyaniline / Comments on pre-print versions of papers
I have no problem with comments to the discussion about Attars/Scantlebury's
paper and my comment coming in through this CORROS-L mailing list.
At 17:56 09.02.98 BST, you (Bob Cottis) wrote:
>I would urge Dr Wessling *not* to do this, as it will cause
>significant confusion for future readers of JCSE, ... Dr Wessling's
proposal does not add anything to
>the existing availability of CORROS-L, and only tends to confuse the
>situation ...
>
>For these reasons, I would also urge readers who wish to do so to
>discuss this paper through this list, rather than by placing their
>comments directly on Dr Wessling's site. This way they can ensure
>that the discussion is properly accessible to future readers.
>
>Bob Cottis
I would like to encourage to discuss here in this group, I will only take
care of having all comments be gathered in the publicly available server
(http://www.ormecon.de/) on its special pages.
I agree, that official comments (published in JCSE) should only be made to
accepted and fixed papers; what I am trying to encourage, is an unofficial,
but nevertheless serious, active and productive discussion about a
scientific paper (and maybe about several other to come).
Let's try!
Dr. Bernhard Wessling
ORMECON CHEMIE GmbH & Co., KG a subsidiary of Zipperling Kessler & Co.
Ferdinand-Harten-Str. 7
D-22949 Ammersbek
Germany
email
wessling@zipperling.do.eunet.de
Tel
+49-40-604 106-18
Fax
+49-40-604 106-52
web site
http://www.ormecon.de/ http://www.zipperling.de/
